Custom Engagement Rings in St Louis Cherry Pick Diamonds
What Kind of Ring Do You Fancy?
Hundreds of settings ready to try on, lifetime warranty included, and a team of GIA‑trained jewelers serving Clayton and St.Louis area since 2003.From classic solitaires to modern lab‑grown hidden halos, our engagement rings give St. Louis couples every option in one place—hundreds of settings, diamonds hand‑selected for sparkle, and a design team ready to tailor the details to your style and budget. Each ring comes with lifetime sizing, inspections, and cleanings, so the piece you choose today stays brilliant for decades to come.
READ MORE
Quality first
Looking for engagement rings St Louis couples trust? Our showroom carries classic solitaires, intricate vintage settings, and modern options in both Natural and Lab Created Diamonds—plus a full custom studio if you’d like something truly personal. Explore our matching wedding bands, learn about diamond shapes, or discover our custom jewelry services, all in one place.
FAQs
How long does it take to have a ring sized? Most in‑house sizing are ready in 3-5 business days.
Why Shop for Engagement Rings and jewelry With Us?
-Voted Best Jewelry Designs– St Louis
-Lifetime cleaning, and manufacturing warranty
-30‑day upgrade guarantee on natural and lab‑grown diamond Jewelry (excluding custom designs)
Does my ring has a warranty ? Yes ! we have a lifetime guarantee on the structure of your piece excluding melee diamonds and sizing
What St Louis Couples Say?
"10/10 recommend Ari at Cherry Pick. He made the experience so easy and was so knowledgeable. Will recommend him to all my friends, and will do future shopping here as well! Awesome experience and made a huge purchase very very easy! " Tony V
Featured product
The infamous TANGIER from our BOLD collection, 14k yellow&white gold solitaire set with an unusual Cushion 3.52 carats Natural Diamond J I1 GIA
This content type will accept rich text to help with adding styles and links to additional pages or content. Use this to add supplementary information to help your buyers.
You can use product metafields to assign content to this tab that is unique to an individual product. Use tabs to highlight unique features, sizing information, or other sales information.
Cherry Pick Your Diamond – The Way It Should Be
When you work with a private jeweler, the experience is completely different:
- View multiple loose GIA-certified diamonds side-by-side
- Compare cut, color, clarity, and carat in real lighting
- Get honest, pressure-free guidance
- Access diamonds from wholesale networks—not just store inventory
Our process is built for clients who want control, transparency, and better value.
Your private jewler in clayton and st.Louis
Cherry Pick Diamonds | Private Diamond Dealer – St. Louis, Missouri
Looking for a private jeweler in St. Louis who lets you truly control the diamond buying process? At Cherry Pick Diamonds, we specialize in helping clients hand-select loose diamonds through a personalized, appointment-only experience.
Unlike traditional jewelry stores, we don’t push pre-set inventory. Instead, we give you access to carefully sourced, high-quality diamonds—so you can choose the exact stone that fits your standards, not someone else’s sales goals.
Why Choose a Private Jeweler in St. Louis?
Most retail jewelry stores in St. Louis carry limited inventory and are incentivized to sell what’s already in stock. That often means compromising on quality or overpaying.
Cherry Pick Diamonds offers a better way:
- We source diamonds specifically for you
- We prioritize cut quality and brilliance
- We show you multiple options—not just one
- We help you understand exactly what you’re buying
This is how smart buyers purchase diamonds.
Pick your diamond
Our Diamond Selection Process
- Consultation (In-Person or Virtual)
Tell us your budget, shape, and preferences. - Diamond Sourcing
We pull a curated selection of diamonds that meet your criteria. - Private Viewing Appointment
Compare stones side-by-side under magnification and natural lighting. - Expert Guidance
Learn how to evaluate diamonds like a professional. - Secure Your Stone
Choose with confidence—no pressure, no gimmicks.
Serving St. Louis and Surrounding Areas
We work with clients across the St. Louis region, including:
- Clayton
- Chesterfield
- St. Charles
- Ladue
- Frontenac
Appointments are private and scheduled to give you a focused, one-on-one experience.
Learn how to determine the best diamond size that suites you
Who This Is For
- Want the best diamond for their budget
- Prefer a private, exclusive and no-pressure environment
- Care about quality over branding
- Are buying an engagement ring or investment-grade diamond
If that sounds like you, you’re in the right place.
Book Your Private Appointment
Ready to cherry pick your diamond?
Schedule a private consultation with Cherry Pick Diamonds and experience a smarter way to buy.
👉 Contact us today to get started.
Our showroom
CHERRY PICK DIAMONDS
230 S Bemiston Ave #1020,
St. Louis, MO 63105
Mon - Fri, By Appointment
Saturday, By Appointment
Sunday, Closed